Ananda offer RM4.20 to take Astro private
Filed Under (Business News) by Webmaster on 11-05-2010
Tagged Under : Ananda Krishnan, Astro, private
JPMorgan Securities (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd reckons the fair value of Astro All Asia Networks plc shares is between RM3.60 and RM4.20, thereby indicating that the takeover offer by T. Ananda Krishnan at RM4.30 per share is priced fairly.
JPMorgan and Public Investment Bank had been engaged as independent advisers by Astro’s board of directors. The bank also advised investors to accept the offer.
However, JPMorgan had clarified that its valuation of Astro’s fair price did not take into account the arbitration award that Astro had won against its Indonesian partner.
JPMorgan Malaysia managing director Didi Yahya, in a letter dated May 7, said the valuation did not take into account any amounts to be received by or which were due to Astro.
To recap, arbitrators in Singapore had ordered James Riady’s Lippo Group to pay RM782mil to Astro after the company lost RM1.16bil in a failed Indonesian pay-TV venture. However, observers have raised doubts that Astro would be able to recover the entire amount.
Astro Holdings made a conditional takeover of Astro on March 17 for RM4.30 per share. Astro Holdings is a special-purpose vehicle in which Ananda has a 58% stake via Usaha Tegas Sdn Bhd, with another 30% held by Khazanah Nasional Bhd and the remainder by a number of bumiputra companies.
Meanwhile, Astro’s board of directors said in a circular to shareholders yesterday that the offer price was above the highest traded price achieved in the two-and-a-half years preceding the notice for the takeover offer and was at a premium of 23.6% over the company’s last traded market price on March 12.
Public Investment Bank said the offer provided an avenue for shareholders to realise their investment at a reasonable premium and enable them to avoid a period of substantial capital outlay the company expected to encounter in the short to medium term due to expansion plans in the domestic and foreign businesses.
However other commentators have opined that the offer price of RM4.30 per share is too low, considering the fact that Ananda had managed to extract more value out of Maxis after the latte’s privatisation in 2007. Furthermore, Astro has a growing business in India, a country whose assets are among the most sought after.

